Site Reputation Abuse Penalty Recovery

So obviously the Site Reputation Abuse update has sort of settled a bit now - I'm not going to do a full history of what the SRA is or who it's affected and all that because those are available elsewhere, but what I am going to do is think out loud for a few hundred words about what the sites who've been hit by it might do moving forward.

Step One

At this point I think it's fairly clearly that what Google wants is for any content it deems to be in violation of the SRA policy is to move that content over onto a separate domain - I've seen sites try to be selective about what they get rid of and every single one of these have not been successful, and when you look at a few penalty notices from Google this isn't surprising.

Most sites will have been told that /folder was an issue, potentially leading them to believe that there may be sections within that folder that were saveable; however I've seen one penalty notice highlighting that the problem was limited to pages that matched /folder/best-, which to me is a fairly good indicator that Google is being exactly as specific as they want to be when they tell you the location of the issue, and nothing that matches the string given to you can be saved.

I've also seen sites arguing against their SRA, often using provably correct facts that demonstrate that they are (or at least the example urls given by Google) do not fail the SRA policy by any sensible reading, and while that would maybe work in a court of law, I really don't see it working in the court of the reconsideration request section of GSC. Yes, it is weird that Wirecutter got away with it, but I think we need to accept the hand we've been dealt.

Just Briefly: Wirecutter

Wirecutter IS an interesting one, to be fair. I have a theory, and forgive me if it seems particularly conspiratorial: I think that Wirecutter got a bit of a pass because everyone agrees Wirecutter is good, and if Wirecutter took a hit there would be a lot of "Google can't tell the difference between algo slop and genuine content" criticism flying around - although to be honest I am surprised they haven't taken a lot more flak on the back of this, given that they have identified the nut of a problem and decided to crack it with an 800 ton hydraulic press. To me it's fairly clear that these manual penalties are the result of Google being made to look silly, so the punishment is 50% spite, 50% face-saving, and that's why the sites that arguably do this stuff but that people like got a pass. UPDATE: A couple of days after I wrote this Google announced a partnership between Google Shopping and Wirecutter so I don't think we need to think too hard about what actually happened.

Anyway

So, more and more SEOs are coming to terms with the fact that a new domain is likely to be the only chance they have to take the content, put it somewhere and have that content rank - but the question stands, just how long is it going to take to get that content to rank and what can we do to expedite it?

Way I see it, there's a few different options, some riskier than others. As I type these words I'm not sure what I'd recommend, but that's kind of what I wanted to think out loud about today.

Option 1: Redirect Penalised Pages to New Site

Google has pretty much said outright that this is likely to pass the SRA penalty to the new domain, making a lot of people pull the shocked Pikachu face for some reason. It stands to reason (to me at least) that attempting to funnel the equity from site A into site B is still using the totality (or near enough) of the ranking power of the "abusive" URL to rank, even once that url no longer has a penalty against it. Might work short term, but Google has already called it out and will be looking for it.

Option 2: Equity Laundering

I would love to have the ability to try this.

Let's say you own penalised.com, and you're moving the content over to new-site.com.

Let's also say you own middleman.com.

Do you reckon you'd get away with redirecting to middleman.com, then redirecting to new-site.com? I personally am not 100% sure - I think you'd see some success in the short term, but remember that these are manually issued penalties, and even once they're cleared I feel like these previously penalised urls will be kept an eye on.

I don't have a ton of data to back this up, but one site I'm aware of, who somewhat coincidentally happened to move their (now penalised) content from one folder to another a couple of weeks before the penalty was issued, has seen an enormous spike in Googlebot Other crawling both the old and current urls - they're currently sat at 62% of their Google requests coming from Google Other, and it almost exclusively crawls penalised urls and the folder that the penalised content used to sit on. Maybe I'm paranoid, but that just seems like they're making sure there's no funny business (other than their own) going on, and as a result I'm fairly certain that if those urls start redirecting anywhere someone will be checking out what they're doing.

As I sit here I'm now thinking of a harebrained scheme where you take unrelated (and crucially, unpenalised) urls with equity that you don't mind losing and redirecting them to new content - so say redirecting /best-ice-creams/ on your main site to /credit-cards/ on your new site, then allowing Google to recontextualise the content on the page and reindex it accordingly.

Is it a stupid, inefficient way to pass equity? Yeah. Is it better than a url going from a standing start? Probably! Will it get you a penalty? Who knows! It's stupid enough that it might work!

Option 3: Links

Sticky. We know that whatever Google says, links are still a big part of ranking, and so at first blush it would seem fairly dangerous to link to content from a formerly penalised site to a new domain.

However, I have to say I'm not convinced.

Why?

Well, number one, the penalty was, by definition, not applied to an entire website. Your homepage was never affected, nor your articles or your PDPs or whatever. Secondly, Google can do a lot of things, but I'm pretty sure even they can't argue that one business shouldn't link to another business in their portfolio, even in header navs or other "prime" linking spots. I used to work for a group of sites who link to each other when and where it made sense to, and despite those sites having backlink spam penalties at the same time as each other (thus both receiving backlinks from a penalised site!) there was never any recommendation to remove or nofollow/noindex those links, and both sites had those penalties lifted once some very painstaking work was done on the link profiles while keeping those reciprocal links (remember them?) in place.

Option 4: Brand

Don't forget that if your folder has been tanked, you still have your brand. People don't necessarily see CNN Underscored and CNN as separate things, so when it comes to the sort of access the brand can get in terms of PR etc, you're absolutely not going from a standing start.

Also, to be frank, most of your competitors have also just got absolutely annihilated as well and the SERPs flooded with crap, so now's the time to take what early mover advantage there is in this situation and get moving - it's only going to be harder in six months when all your competitors have given up and done the same thing.

The Other Stuff

The sort of content that got battered by SRA is, to be frank, the sort of content discover will absolutely eat up.

There's paid ads (Which admittedly will be expensive).

I hate to say it, but is there any space for an extra display ad here and there on the main site to help shore up budget?

There's a brand new social media platform which is already driving more traffic than Twitter to some platforms, which your social team should be all over regardless.

There's video, both long and short form. Podcasts, too.

Whisper it, but there are indexing services if you know where to look.

It's going to suck and it's going to be a pain and it's going to be harder than it was, but that is unfortunately exactly what Google wants - and ultimately we want these rankings back because we know there's money on the table, so it's got to be worth at least trying, right?