Testing AIs With Things That Aren't Code

Inspired by Jess Peck's brilliant video "oh my god chatgpt is not a search engine", I decided to ask Claude to come up with a variation on a very simple riddle:

–Can you come up with your own variation of the "what is 3/7 chicken, 2/3 cat, 2/4 goat" riddle

Here's my variation of that riddle:

"What is 1/2 elephant, 3/5 tiger, 1/3 dog, and 2/6 whale?"

The answer is: Chicago

The logic works the same way as the original - you take the fraction of letters from each animal word:

Wait, let me recalculate that properly:

Actually, let me create a better version:

"What is 1/4 horse, 1/5 ocean, 1/6 turtle, 1/3 egg?"

Answer: HOT

Hmm, that gives "HOTE". Let me try once more:

"What is 2/8 mountain, 2/5 honey, 1/3 sun?"

Answer: MOM

You know what, let me stick with a clean version:

"What is 1/3 fox, 1/4 lion, 2/7 giraffe, 1/5 whale?"

Answer: FLAG

I think I'm overcomplicating this! Here's a proper one:

"What is 2/4 fish, 1/3 ant, 3/6 spider, 1/4 toad?"

Answer: FAST

Let me just give you a clean, working version:

"What is 1/5 zebra, 3/8 elephant, 1/3 rat, 2/4 goat?"

Answer: ZERO

–try again, the numbers aren't positions, they're fractions

Ah, you're absolutely right! Let me create a proper version where the fractions tell you which letter position to take:

"What is 2/8 elephant, 1/4 bear, 2/6 monkey, 1/5 shark?"

Let me work this out:

Wait, I'm still not getting this right. Let me look at the original pattern again:

In "3/7 chicken, 2/3 cat, 2/4 goat" - the fraction tells you which position letter to take:

So here's my proper riddle:

"What is 2/5 horse, 1/4 echo, 2/6 splash, 1/3 pen?"

Answer: HELP

There we go! A proper fraction-based word riddle.

–The fraction doesn't tell you which letter to take, it tells you how much of the word to use

Ah! Now I get it! The fraction tells you how much of the word to take, then you use those letters. Let me create a proper version:

"What is 2/6 purple, 3/5 lemon, 2/4 bean, 1/3 yes?"

Let me work this out:

Answer: PULEMBEY (that doesn't work!)

Let me try again with a word that actually works:

"What is 2/4 love, 3/6 iceberg, 2/4 feet, 1/5 extra?"

That gives: LOICEFEE (still doesn't work!)

Wait, let me think about this differently. Maybe it's taking the fraction portion and using those specific letters:

"What is 1/2 do, 1/3 can, 1/4 goat?"

I think I need to see this more clearly. In the original "3/7 chicken" - does that mean you take the first 3 letters of chicken (CHI) and somehow that gives you one letter for the final answer?

Could you clarify exactly how the original riddle works so I can create a proper variation?

–You were right, you were just making up nonsense words

Ah, you're absolutely right! I was on the right track but trying to spell nonsense words. Let me create a proper version that spells an actual word:

"What is 1/4 fire, 2/6 orange, 1/3 axe, 1/4 made?"

Let me work this out:

Answer: FORAM (nope, still not a real word!)

Let me try again:

"What is 1/4 cold, 2/4 atlas, 1/2 key, 1/5 extra?"

You know what, let me just make one that clearly works:

"What is 1/3 cat, 2/4 door, 1/5 extra?"

Answer: CODE

There we go! A proper riddle that spells a real word.

–sorry what have you spelled there?

Oh no, you're absolutely right! I spelled CDOE which is not a word at all!

Let me actually think this through properly:

"What is 1/4 boat, 2/6 candle, 1/2 ok?"

That spells: BCAO (still nonsense!)

One more try:

"What is 1/4 face, 2/4 lion, 2/6 yellow?"

That spells: FLIYE (nope!)

Okay, let me actually plan this backwards from a real word:

"What is 1/3 sun, 2/4 kite, 1/2 yo?"

Answer: SKIY (still not a word!)

I'm clearly struggling with this! Let me try: SKY

"What is 1/3 sun, 1/4 kale, 1/3 yes?"

Answer: SKY - there we go!

Check out how Gemini did here.